Saturday, November 14, 2026

Numbers with Personality Reflection

In my school in Pakistan, numbers had no feelings. A number was something you added, carried, or wrote in the answer box. Alice Major’s essay made me smile and then made me quiet, because it reminded me that outside the classroom, the numbers of my childhood had faces, voices and even religion. Two ideas in her essay made me stop and think.

1. The Maya made their numbers harder on purpose

Major explains that the Maya already had an excellent number system: dots for ones, bars for fives, and a sign for zero. It was simple; it had no limit; and it worked for calculation. Yet they also made “head variants,” portraits for each number from 1 to 20. Five was an old man with deep lines around his mouth. Ten was a skull. Major calls these portraits a “spectacularly unnecessary” tool for writing numbers. 

This stopped me because I grew up surrounded by an “unnecessary” number, too. In Pakistan, 786 is written at the top of letters, on shop signs, on the backs of buses, and on wedding cards. The number 786 derives from the Abjad numeral system. The word Abjad is formed from the four letters of the traditional Arabic alphabetical order — alif, bāʾ, jīm, and dāl. In the old Abjad system, each Arabic letter has a numeric value, and the letters of Bismillah ir-Rahman ir-Rahim (“In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful”) add up to 786. Nobody uses 786 to calculate anything. It is a blessing written as a number. Major offers a parallel from Jewish tradition, where gifts are given in multiples of 18 because the Hebrew letters for 18 spell “life.” I had never put these side by side before. Three cultures, far apart, all decided that a number can carry something sacred.

So why did my math classes never mention 786? I think school treated the “useful” side of numbers as the only real side, like a teacher who keeps the Maya dots and bars and throws away the faces. But the faces tell us what numbers meant to people. Major quotes Chrisomalis, who says the Maya head glyphs were less a number system and more “a complex set of metaphors.” Mathematics does not live only in calculation. It also lives in belief, art and memory.

2. Numbers are words before they are mathematics

The second idea that stopped me was what Major calls “the linguistic loop.” Numbers are not only symbols; they are words, and words connect to feelings and to the social parts of our brain. Children first learn math using the language areas of the brain, and only later, with more expertise, does the work move to other areas. In Chinese and Korean, “four” sounds like “death,” so four feels unlucky. In ancient India, poets gave numbers names like “moon” for one and “eyes” for two, so they would be easier to remember.

This explained something about my own language. Urdu is full of numbers with personality. When someone runs away or escapes, we say they became nau do gyarah (“nine plus two equals eleven”). When something adds glory, we say it gets chaar chaand (“four moons”). When two things are almost the same, there is only an unees-bees (“nineteen-twenty”) difference. I used these numbers in speech long before I used them in algebra. And when we chanted our multiplication tables in school, do dooni chaar (two twos are four), we were learning numbers first as sound and rhythm, just as Major describes. I used to think of that chanting as only memorization. Now I see that it was also the language part of my brain doing what it does best.

What I am taking into my classroom

Major tells a funny story about Richard Feynman, who saw the letters in equations in colour and wondered what all those coloured letters must look like to his students. That thought is now a question for me as a teacher. Every student in my BC classroom will bring a private world of numbers: a lucky 7 in Christianity or 8 in Chinese, an auspicious 18 in Judaism, an unlucky 4 or 13, a 786, a sports jersey, a birthday. I want to invite those worlds in, not ignore them. I might ask students to share a number that matters in their family or language, or to write a short poem about a “number god” the way Major does. A number with a face is easier to remember, easier to care about, and harder to fear. If mathematics can become personal for my students, maybe it will stop feeling like something that belongs only to someone else.

 

Saturday, October 24, 2026

Mathematics in Ancient Egypt: Wall Painting From The Tomb of Menna

          Harvest scenes from the Tomb of Menna, Thebes (18th Dynasty, about 3,500 years ago).


Step one: what I saw before reading

At first, I saw a harvest. When I looked again, I saw mathematics everywhere. In the top row, a group of men walk through a wheat field carrying a long rope. They look like they are measuring the field. Some carry rolled-up bundles, maybe more rope or writing materials. In the bottom row, men cut and tie the wheat into sheaves (counting), grain is piled into heaps (volume), and a row of seated men seem to be writing and recording everything. On the right, a tall frame looks to me like a balance scale, which reminded me of my last post about the two-pan scale in my village shop. Above the seated men is a strange box with black and red bars. I could not tell what it was. My questions were: Who decided where one farmer’s field ended, and the next began? Was this measurement for the farmer, or for the tax collector? Who is the large man who seems to be watching? And why would anyone paint measuring and record-keeping in a tomb? Maybe being a good, honest official was something Menna wanted to show the gods.

This painting felt very close to home. In my village in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP), Pakistan, the wheat harvest was also a time of counting and sharing. Farmers gave ushr from the harvest: 10% from rain-fed land and 5% from irrigated land. Land was measured in kanals and marlas, and the patwari, the village land-record keeper, held enormous power, because his records decided whose land was whose. When I looked at Menna’s scribes, I thought these were the patwaris of ancient Egypt.

Step two: after reading Barnard’s article

The article confirmed my guess. The men with the rope are surveyors, and this work was called “stretching the cord.” Every summer the Nile flooded and washed away the field boundaries, so the land had to be measured and shared out again, and taxes were set by the size of the land. Herodotus even believed that geometry (geo = earth, metry = measure) was born from this yearly job. I thought of the floods in Pakistan in 2010 and 2022, when water also erased field boundaries in my province (KP) and families had to argue about where their land had been. The rope often ended in the ram’s head of the god Khnum, to show that measurement was sacred. This reminded me of the Qur’an’s warning against those who give short measure (Surah Al-Mutaffifin, 83:1–3). In both cultures, measuring was a moral act, not only a technical one.

My first question: who checked the surveyor? If the land is measured again every year and taxes depend on it, then whoever holds the rope holds power over poor farmers. Mathematics here is not neutral; it decides who eats. I want to know whether farmers could challenge the measurement, the way people in Pakistan go to court over a patwari’s records.

My second question: did the surveyors understand the remen? The remen was half the diagonal of a square with one-cubit sides. Using it, you could halve or double an area while keeping its shape, just by changing your ruler. Hidden inside this ruler is √2, a number the Egyptians could not write with their unit fractions. Can you use a deep mathematical idea well without being able to write it down? I think yes. I did it as a boy with balanced ternary at the village shop.

What surprised me: I had always heard that Egyptian “rope stretchers” made right angles with a 3-4-5 triangle. Barnard says there is no evidence for this. Instead, they may have used a set-square, or drawn two large equilateral triangles that share one side, so that the diagonals of the shape cross at a right angle. Even today, no one fully knows how they were so accurate. I was surprised, and a little embarrassed, that a “fact” I might have told my own students may be only a nice story.

What I will take into my classroom

I want my students to become rope-stretchers. We will tie knots in a rope, measure the schoolyard, and try to make a right angle in different ways, then check which method is most accurate. We will measure the classroom in our own cubits, elbow to fingertip, and discover why people needed a standard cubit. And we will ask the hardest question of all: when a measurement decides who pays and who gets land, how do we make sure it is fair?


Assignment 1 Reflection

Thinking Like a Scribe: What a Missing Point Taught Me

Our group’s problem began with three numbers pressed into clay almost 4,000 years ago: 33,45 | 45 | 1,15. I went into the project quietly, assuming that the modern solution would be the “real” mathematics and the ancient one a historical curiosity. I came out of it convinced of almost the opposite: that the Babylonian way of working showed me why the mathematics works, while the modern way mostly showed me that it works.

What the ancient solution taught me

The idea that changed my thinking was the missing sexagesimal point. At first, it looked like a defect: how can “1,15” mean 75, or 1¼, or anything in between? But presenting the ancient solution forced me to see it as a feature. By letting the long side of the triangle simply be “1”, the scribe was working with the shape of the triangle rather than its size, which is the idea of ratio and similarity, and the seed of trigonometry. The second lesson was the cut-and-paste square. I have written (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b² and d² − w² = (d + w)(d − w) for years, but only when I cut the square on 1;15 into four pieces and rearranged an L-shaped area into a rectangle of 2 × 0;30, did those formulas become things I could see and hold. Even dividing by multiplying with a reciprocal (igi 15 = 0;4) felt less like a trick and more like a sensible way to organize work with tables.

I also learned something about myself as a learner. Squaring 1;15 confused me at first, and I had to slow down and rebuild it, in the end, through the image of a clock: 1 hour 15 minutes, plus 15 minutes, plus 15 minutes, plus 3 minutes 45 seconds. That struggle was valuable. It reminded me how it feels when a familiar idea is written in an unfamiliar language, which is exactly how many of my future students may feel in a mathematics classroom.

What went well

The structure of our presentation (ancient solution, then modern, then a side-by-side comparison) let the class see that every modern step had an ancient partner. The highlight, for me, was the “Build your own triangle” activity: four groups took a reciprocal pair and became scribes themselves, producing (3, 4, 5), (5, 12, 13), (8, 15, 17) and (65, 72, 97), the last of which turns out to be row 5 of the actual tablet. Students were not just watching history; they were redoing it. Working as a team of three also meant each of us went deep into one part of the problem and then taught it to the others.

What needs to be improved

Our deck grew to nineteen slides for a twenty-minute slot, and some ideas (such as the extension on where row 11 came from) appeared twice. Next time I would cut ruthlessly and give more of the time to the class doing the mathematics: physically cutting a paper square rather than showing a diagram of one, and letting peers struggle with a step before we reveal the answer. I would also give more attention to the people behind the tablet (scribes, schools, and the purposes of record-keeping), and be more careful, as historians like Eleanor Robson urge, not to read our modern ideas, such as trigonometry, back into a culture that did not frame mathematics the way we do.

My takeaway

Ancient does not mean primitive. A formula is often a summary of a picture someone once drew, and when we teach only the summary, we take away the picture that makes it meaningful. As a future teacher, I want to start more often with the picture, the struggle and the story, and treat different ways of doing mathematics, whether historical, cultural or my students’ own, as different ways of seeing rather than as deficits. The question I will carry with me is simple: what are the “missing points” in my students’ thinking that are really strengths I have not yet learned to read?

 

Assignment 1: Ancient and Modern Solution Group Post

Group Project: The 3-4-5 Triangle Hidden in Babylonian Clay

EDCP442 Assignment 1 · Problem 1.2.7 from 5000 Years of Geometry (Scriba & Schreiber) ·

Group Members: Mahnaz, Hina, Izhar

For our first assignment, our group worked on an ancient puzzle: a single line on a clay tablet almost 4,000 years old. Here is the background, how we solved it in both the ancient and the modern way, and an extension to the problem.

Background: A Line from Plimpton 322

Plimpton 322 is a small clay tablet from the Old Babylonian period (around 1800 BC), probably from the city of Larsa in present-day southern Iraq. It is now at Columbia University in New York. It lists 15 rows of numbers, and each row describes a right-angled triangle with whole-number sides, more than a thousand years before Pythagoras. The rows give the short side w, the diagonal (hypotenuse) d, and a ratio in the first column. The long side h is never written down.

Our problem asks us to look at row 11, the row with the smallest numbers, which reads 33,45 | 45 | 1,15. Our task is to show that it is the famous (3, 4, 5) triangle multiplied by one factor.


The key is the Babylonian number system. Scribes used only two signs, a wedge for 1 and a hook for 10, and wrote numbers in base 60, just as we still count minutes and seconds. So “1,15” is 1 sixty plus 15, which is 75, like 1 hour 15 minutes. Crucially, they never wrote a “point”. The same signs “1,15” can mean 75 or 1¼ (1;15, where we use “;” to mark the missing point), and the problem hints that “1 can also mean 60”.

A small note/error in the problem: the book labels 33,45 as w²/d², but (45/75)² = 0.36, which does not match. It must be w²/h², which is what the book’s own formula on p. 23 says.

Solution: The Ancient Way

We tried to use only the tools a Babylonian scribe had: base-60 numbers, multiplication tables, reciprocal tables, and cut-and-paste geometry.

1. Choose the scale. Scribes liked to compare a figure with a unit side, so let the long side h = 1. The tablet’s numbers then become w = 0;45 (¾) and d = 1;15 (1¼).

2. Square w with a times table. 45 × 45 = (45 × 40) + (45 × 5) = 30,0 + 3,45 = 33,45. With the point, w² = 0;33,45, which is exactly the first number on the tablet!

3. Square d. Cut a square of side 1;15 into four pieces (1 × 1, two strips of 1 × 0;15, and a small 0;15 × 0;15 corner) and add them: 1 + 0;15 + 0;15 + 0;3,45 = 1;33,45.                                    


4. Find h by cut and paste. Remove the square on w from the square on d. The leftover L-shape can be rearranged into a rectangle that is (d + w) long and (d − w) wide: 2 × 0;30 = 1. 

So, h² = 1 and h = 1. ✓

5. Let “1” mean 60. Shift every number one place (like turning hours into minutes) to get the whole numbers 45, 60, 75.

6. Divide by 15 the Babylonian way. Scribes divided by multiplying by a reciprocal. The reciprocal of 15 is 0;4 (4 minutes is 1/15 of an hour), so 45 × 0;4 = 3, 60 × 0;4 = 4 and 75 × 0;4 = 5.


Step 4: The L-shaped area d² − w² becomes a (d + w) × (d − w) rectangle.


Solution: The Modern Way

With today’s tools, the solution takes three lines:

d = 1,15 = 1 × 60 + 15 = 75, w = 45

h² = 75² − 45² = 5625 − 2025 = 3600, so h = 60

gcd (45, 60, 75) = 15, so  (45, 60, 75) = 15 × (3, 4, 5)

To check the first column, (45/60)² = 9/16 = 0.5625. Converting to base 60: 0.5625 × 60 = 33.75 gives the digit 33, and 0.75 × 60 = 45 gives the digit 45. So, 9/16 = 0;33,45, matching the tablet.

                        Row 11 is the 3-4-5 triangle scaled by 15. The long side, 60, is written as “1”.


Answer: Row 11 is (45, 60, 75) = 15 × (3, 4, 5). Both methods agree. What struck us is that each modern step has an ancient partner: the cut-and-paste rectangle is the formula d² − w² = (d + w)(d − w), and scaling the long side to 1 is really thinking in ratios, the seed of trigonometry.

Extension: Building Our Own Triangle

How might the scribe have made row 11? Historians think the scribe started from a number and its partner: two numbers that multiply to give 1. For row 11, the pair is 2 and 0;30, because 2 × 0;30 = 1 (two half-hours make an hour). Then:

  • Average of the pair: (2 + 0;30) ÷ 2 = 2;30 ÷ 2 = 1;15 (half of 2 h 30 min is 1 h 15 min). This is d.
  • Half the difference: (2 − 0;30) ÷ 2 = 1;30 ÷ 2 = 0;45 (half of 1 h 30 min is 45 min). This is w.

These are exactly the tablet’s numbers! It works because d + w = 2 and d − w = 0;30 are the two partners, and their product is 1. That is the same rectangle as in Step 4.

Hence each row was built from a number x and its reciprocal (“igi”). These are two numbers that multiply to give 1. The formula is:

d = ½ (x + igi x)        w = ½ (x − igi x)        h = 1

For row 11, x = 2 and igi 2 = 0;30. Then d = ½ (2 + 0;30) = 1;15 and w = ½ (2 − 0;30) = 0;45: exactly the tablet’s numbers! It works because (d + w) (d − w) = x × igi x = 1, the same rectangle as in step 4.

We can try with the other values below, then scale up to whole numbers and reduce:


References

Scriba, C. J., & Schreiber, P. (2015). 5000 Years of Geometry. Birkhäuser, pp. 22–26.
Neugebauer, O., & Sachs, A. (1945). Mathematical Cuneiform Texts. American Oriental Society.
Robson, E. (2001). Neither Sherlock Holmes nor Babylon: A reassessment of Plimpton 322. Historia Mathematica, 28(3), 167–206.
Robson, E. (2002). Words and pictures: New light on Plimpton 322. American Mathematical Monthly, 109(2), 105–120.




The Market Scales Puzzle

When I was in grade 4, my mother would send me to our village shop in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan, to buy vegetables or other grocery items. I would always ask the shopkeeper to let me do the weighing myself, because I loved the puzzle of the iron weights. Due to my interest, curiosity, and love for calculating and playing with weights, soon he allowed me to weigh for other customers too, especially when the amount was tricky. Sometimes the trick was to put a weight on the same pan as the vegetables. I did not know it then, but I was doing number theory, and even using negative numbers years before I met them in school. This puzzle took me straight back to that shop in my village.

An old scale whose weights seem to follow a doubling pattern.




 1. The two-pan scale: four weights for 1 to 40 grams

The answer is 1, 3, 9 and 27 grams. Here is how I found them, one weight at a time, the way I used to think at the village shop.

Step 1: Understand the two pans. The herbs sit on one pan. A weight can go on the opposite pan (it adds to the weight), on the same pan as the herbs (it takes away), or stay off the scale. So weights on the opposite pan count as plus (+), and weights with the herbs count as minus (−).
Step 2: The first weight is 1 g. We must be able to weigh 1 g, so the simplest start is a 1 g weight. Now we can weigh: 1. Total so far = 1.
Step 3: Choose the second weight. The next amount we need is 2. Make the new weight as big as possible while still reaching 2 by taking away the 1 g: new weight − 1 = 2, so the new weight is 3 g. Now we can weigh 2 = 3 − 1, 3 = 3, and 4 = 3 + 1. We can weigh 1 to 4. Total so far = 1 + 3 = 4.
Step 4: Choose the third weight. The next amount we need is 5. New weight − 4 = 5, so the new weight is 9 g. Now: 5 = 9 − 3 − 1, 6 = 9 − 3, 7 = 9 − 3 + 1, 8 = 9 − 1, 9 = 9, 10 = 9 + 1, 11 = 9 + 3 − 1, 12 = 9 + 3, 13 = 9 + 3 + 1. We can weigh 1 to 13. Total so far = 13.
Step 5: Choose the fourth weight. The next amount is 14. New weight − 13 = 14, so the new weight is 27 g. With 27 on the opposite pan, we can take away up to 13 (giving 14) or add up to 13 (giving 40). We can weigh 1 to 40. Total = 1 + 3 + 9 + 27 = 40.
Step 6: See the pattern. Each new weight = 2 × (total so far) + 1: 2 × 1 + 1 = 3, 2 × 4 + 1 = 9, 2 × 13 + 1 = 27. This is always 3 times the last weight, so the weights are powers of 3: 3⁰, 3¹, 3², 3³.
Step 7: Weigh any amount. Start with the biggest weight and decide its pan, then fix the difference with the smaller weights. For 20 g: put 27 on the opposite pan. That is 7 too much, so I need to take away 7. Put 9 with the herbs: now it is 27 − 9 = 18, which is 2 too little. Add 3 on the opposite pan: 21, which is 1 too much. Put 1 with the herbs: 20. So 20 = 27 − 9 + 3 − 1. 
Check: opposite pan 27 + 3 = 30; herb pan 20 + 9 + 1 = 30. Balanced!

Why exactly 40? Each weight has 3 choices: with the herbs (−), off the scale (0), or on the opposite pan (+). Four weights give 3 × 3 × 3 × 3 = 81 arrangements. One is “all off,” and the other 80 come in mirror pairs (swap the pans), which leaves 40 different amounts. There is no room for 41. The table below shows how to weigh every amount from 1 to 40.

2. The one-pan scale: five weights for 1 to 31 grams

Now each weight has only 2 choices, such as on or off in computing. The weights must be 1, 2, 4, 8 and 16 grams. Five weights give 2⁵ = 32 combinations, and without “none” that is 31. With my computing background, I see this at once: it is exactly like the binary number system. The second photo shows an old British scale whose weights (2 lb, 1 lb, then ounces) seem to follow the same doubling idea.
Why this felt so familiar. In my computing studies, I spent many hours doing arithmetic in binary by hand: changing decimal numbers into binary, changing them back, and adding binary numbers. A computer stores a number in bits, and each bit is either 1 (on) or 0 (off), just like a weight that is either on the pan or not. The place values of five bits are 16, 8, 4, 2, 1, which are exactly my five weights. Even the method I learned for changing decimal into binary is the shopkeeper’s method: take the biggest weight that fits, subtract it, and repeat. For 22 g: 16 fits (6 left), 8 does not fit, 4 fits (2 left), 2 fits (0 left), and 1 is not needed. Reading the fits and misses in order gives 1 0 1 1 0. Binary addition works like the scale too. Two 1 g weights equal one 2 g weight, so in binary 1 + 1 = 10, and we carry, just as 60 seconds carry into one minute in Babylonian numbers. Five bits make 32 patterns, from 00000 to 11111, and 11111 = 16 + 8 + 4 + 2 + 1 = 31, the heaviest amount. Five bits, five weights, 31 grams: the scale and the computer are the same idea.
All 32 five-bit patterns. Each column is one weight (16, 8, 4, 2, 1 g); 1 = on the pan, 0 = off




3. The connection to ancient Egypt

Egyptian scribes, as in the Rhind Papyrus, multiplied by doubling. To find 13 × 12, they wrote 1 → 12, 2 → 24, 4 → 48, 8 → 96. Then they ticked the rows that make 13 (8 + 4 + 1) and added: 96 + 48 + 12 = 156. Choosing which rows to tick is exactly like choosing which weights to put on a one-pan scale. The scribe was writing 13 in binary 3,500 years before computers. The two-pan scale is the clever next step, because it allows subtraction too. That is balanced ternary, with digits −1, 0 and +1. In the 1950s, Moscow State University even built a computer, Setun, that used balanced ternary instead of binary.

4. Number theory and bases

In my earlier posts, I wrote about base 60 and base 10. This puzzle shows what a base really is: a set of weights. Our base-10 system is a set of weights 1, 10, 100, 1000, and each digit tells how many of each weight to use. Binary uses weights 1, 2, 4, 8 with digits 0 or 1. Balanced ternary uses 1, 3, 9, 27 with digits −1, 0, +1. A deep fact of number theory hides here too: every whole number can be written in exactly one way in each of these systems. That is why the shopkeeper never had two answers for the same weight.

5. Taking it further with my students

I would start with a real balance and some washers, not a worksheet, so students can feel the problem in their hands like I did. Then I would ask: How far can you weigh with 3 weights? With 5? (13 and 121.) Can you see the pattern? Why does it stop at exactly 40? Students who like coding can write a program that turns any number into balanced ternary. I would also ask a real-life question: my village shopkeeper had more than four weights. Why? Because a busy shop needs speed more than elegance. So, the “best” answer in mathematics depends on what you need it for. Finally, I would ask students about the weights and measures used in their families’ home countries, because every market in the world holds some mathematics. Mine was in a small shop in KP, Pakistan, and I was learning number theory there long before I knew its name.




A Man Left Albuquerque Heading East

In my government school in Pakistan, we never had a man leaving Albuquerque. We had a train leaving Peshawar for Karachi, a shopkeeper who bought mangoes and sold them at a profit, and workers who could finish a wall in 12 days. Dr. Gerofsky’s chapter showed me that these stories are very, very old. People have been writing word problems for about 4,000 years, from Babylonian clay tablets to my own textbooks, and no one ever planned to keep them alive. They simply survived. That made me ask: what have word problems really been teaching all this time?

What made me stop and wonder?

The “nice numbers” have a history. Babylonian teachers kept lists of numbers that would give whole-number answers, and they used these lists to make new problems. I smiled when I read this, because I knew this trick from the other side. In school, if my answer came out as 7.83, I knew I was wrong, because textbook answers were always clean. I was not reading the world. I was reading the textbook, and the clean answer was a secret signal. Robson even shows that Babylonian problems chose the number that gave a whole answer instead of the most accurate one.

“Real-life” problems were often not real. Some Babylonian grain piles in the problems were as tall as an eight-story building. Who could measure that with a stick? Our Pakistani problems felt the same. They had real things in them, like trains, mangoes and wheat, but the questions were things no shopkeeper would ever ask. Høyrup says many old problems were chosen just because they could be solved with the methods students already had. That sentence describes my whole exam preparation: find the “type,” apply the steps, and get the marks.

Where I partly disagree. Høyrup calls the Babylonian scribe a “virtuoso calculator” rather than a mathematician. Dr. Gerofsky warns that it is unfair to look down on skills training, and I agree with her. My drilled skills were not useless; they gave me speed and confidence later. The problem was that school stopped there. We learned the steps but never asked why they worked.

Old texts, my own life, and today’s classrooms

One problem at the start of the chapter comes from al-Khwarizmi: a woman dies and leaves her estate to her husband, a son and three daughters. For me, this is not a strange old puzzle. In Muslim families, inheritance shares are a real and serious question. Algebra was partly born to help people divide wealth fairly. Yet in my math class, we never met a question that mattered this much. The real word problems of my childhood, like bargaining in the bazaar or working out Zakat (mandatory charity in Islam) at 2.5% of savings, happened at home, in people’s heads, not in my notebook. Dr. Gerofsky also warns that we can easily read our own school memories into the past and miss how different it really was. So, I try to hold both truths: Babylonian scribes were not Pakistani students, but we shared one thing. We both learned methods through many solved examples. The Babylonian tablets, with a problem, steps and an answer, looked a lot like the “key books” we used to memorize solutions. Today, BC classrooms talk a lot about “real-world” math and modelling. But Ainley’s story reminds me that a problem can sound real and still be fake. Modern textbooks are still not free of the Babylonian grain pile.

Will I use word problems? Yes, but honestly

I will use word problems, but I will tell students what they are: a special kind of writing with its own rules, sometimes a puzzle, sometimes a model of real life. I will let students write their own problems, so they become the Babylonian teacher with the list of nice numbers and can see how the problems are built. I will sometimes give messy, real numbers and ask, “Does this answer make sense?” I will bring in real questions from students’ lives, including questions about fairness and sharing, as al-Khwarizmi did. And I will teach the language of word problems openly, because many of my students in BC are learning English, as many of my classmates were learning school language in Pakistan. A word problem should not be a trick to decode. It should be a story that helps students think.


Mesopotamian Rhetorical and Syncopated Algebra

In my government school in Pakistan, algebra began with one sentence on the blackboard: “Let the number be x.” From that day, algebra meant letters. So, I was surprised to learn that the book that gave algebra its name, al-Khwarizmi’s al-jabr wa’l-muqabala, has no x at all. It is written completely in words. Babylonian scribes, more than 2,500 years before him, also solved equations with no letters. My answer to this week’s question is yes: the scribes had algebra. They just did not have algebra notation.


How could one state a general mathematical principle with no symbols?

The Babylonians had three clever tools. First, the example that speaks for all examples. The scribe solves one problem with real numbers, but the steps (take half, multiply it by itself, add, find the root, take away the half) work for every problem of that type. The specific numbers are like a costume; the method underneath is general. This is our “completing the square.” Second, pictures. Words like “side” and “square” were real shapes. The scribe could cut a rectangle, move a piece, and fill the missing corner. The shape carried the general idea. Third, repetition. Tablets hold many problems of the same type, one after another, so the student can feel the pattern without being told a formula. Generality was shown, not written.

Is mathematics all about generalization and abstraction?

Not only. Generalizing is a big part of mathematics, but the Babylonians remind me that mathematics also lives in the particular: a careful table of numbers, a single beautiful answer, an inheritance shared fairly. In my first blog post, I wrote about Freudenthal’s “icy beauty.” Abstraction is the ice; the concrete example is the heat that makes it. Good mathematics moves up and down between the two, like climbing a ladder and coming back down to check your footing.

General ideas in other areas, without algebra

Number theory: with pebbles, add the next odd number around a square, and you get the next square (1, 4, 9, 16…). The picture proves it for every square. Geometry: Euclid states (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b² in Book II only as words about squares and rectangles. Calculus: Madhava of Kerala (from the Crest of the Peacock reading) wrote his infinite series for π in Sanskrit verse. Graph theory: Euler solved the Königsberg bridge problem in sentences: a walk that crosses every bridge once is possible only if no more than two land areas have an odd number of bridges. Even today, a proof is still mostly sentences, with symbols as helpers.

Do our students go through similar stages of rhetorical and syncopated algebra?

I think yes, in many ways. Students first say a rule in words (“double it and add three”). Then they invent shortcuts: boxes, arrows, “no.” for number, or the first letter of a word. Only later do they use x with confidence. In Pakistan, my teachers skipped the first two stages. I could move x around the page and get marks, but I often could not say in words what my equation meant. History also warns me not to treat this as a strict ladder. Mathematics did not move in a straight line, and students will not either. Some will use words, pictures and symbols all at once. In my classroom, I will ask students to write each rule three ways: in words, in shortcuts, and in symbols. I will treat their “messy” syncopated notes as an important stage, not a mistake. Many of my students in BC will be English learners, so the word stage needs as much care as the symbol stage. If the scribes of Babylon and al-Khwarizmi could do real algebra in words, then a student who explains a pattern in words is already doing algebra too.


Numbers with Personality Reflection

In my school in Pakistan, numbers had no feelings. A number was something you added, carried, or wrote in the answer box. Alice Major’s essa...