Saturday, October 24, 2026

Mesopotamian Rhetorical and Syncopated Algebra

In my government school in Pakistan, algebra began with one sentence on the blackboard: “Let the number be x.” From that day, algebra meant letters. So, I was surprised to learn that the book that gave algebra its name, al-Khwarizmi’s al-jabr wa’l-muqabala, has no x at all. It is written completely in words. Babylonian scribes, more than 2,500 years before him, also solved equations with no letters. My answer to this week’s question is yes: the scribes had algebra. They just did not have algebra notation.


How could one state a general mathematical principle with no symbols?

The Babylonians had three clever tools. First, the example that speaks for all examples. The scribe solves one problem with real numbers, but the steps (take half, multiply it by itself, add, find the root, take away the half) work for every problem of that type. The specific numbers are like a costume; the method underneath is general. This is our “completing the square.” Second, pictures. Words like “side” and “square” were real shapes. The scribe could cut a rectangle, move a piece, and fill the missing corner. The shape carried the general idea. Third, repetition. Tablets hold many problems of the same type, one after another, so the student can feel the pattern without being told a formula. Generality was shown, not written.

Is mathematics all about generalization and abstraction?

Not only. Generalizing is a big part of mathematics, but the Babylonians remind me that mathematics also lives in the particular: a careful table of numbers, a single beautiful answer, an inheritance shared fairly. In my first blog post, I wrote about Freudenthal’s “icy beauty.” Abstraction is the ice; the concrete example is the heat that makes it. Good mathematics moves up and down between the two, like climbing a ladder and coming back down to check your footing.

General ideas in other areas, without algebra

Number theory: with pebbles, add the next odd number around a square, and you get the next square (1, 4, 9, 16…). The picture proves it for every square. Geometry: Euclid states (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b² in Book II only as words about squares and rectangles. Calculus: Madhava of Kerala (from the Crest of the Peacock reading) wrote his infinite series for π in Sanskrit verse. Graph theory: Euler solved the Königsberg bridge problem in sentences: a walk that crosses every bridge once is possible only if no more than two land areas have an odd number of bridges. Even today, a proof is still mostly sentences, with symbols as helpers.

Do our students go through similar stages of rhetorical and syncopated algebra?

I think yes, in many ways. Students first say a rule in words (“double it and add three”). Then they invent shortcuts: boxes, arrows, “no.” for number, or the first letter of a word. Only later do they use x with confidence. In Pakistan, my teachers skipped the first two stages. I could move x around the page and get marks, but I often could not say in words what my equation meant. History also warns me not to treat this as a strict ladder. Mathematics did not move in a straight line, and students will not either. Some will use words, pictures and symbols all at once. In my classroom, I will ask students to write each rule three ways: in words, in shortcuts, and in symbols. I will treat their “messy” syncopated notes as an important stage, not a mistake. Many of my students in BC will be English learners, so the word stage needs as much care as the symbol stage. If the scribes of Babylon and al-Khwarizmi could do real algebra in words, then a student who explains a pattern in words is already doing algebra too.


1 comment:

  1. Izhar, I would love to see you working and publishing in mathematics education and the history of mathematics. Wonderful insights throughout! I especially love your examples of mathematical generalization without algebra -- and your insights about the 'heaping up of examples' (as my mentor David Pimm would often say!) as a reasonable way of expressing generalization at times before algebra was available to people.

    ReplyDelete

Numbers with Personality Reflection

In my school in Pakistan, numbers had no feelings. A number was something you added, carried, or wrote in the answer box. Alice Major’s essa...