Saturday, October 24, 2026

Assignment 1 Reflection

Thinking Like a Scribe: What a Missing Point Taught Me

Our group’s problem began with three numbers pressed into clay almost 4,000 years ago: 33,45 | 45 | 1,15. I went into the project quietly, assuming that the modern solution would be the “real” mathematics and the ancient one a historical curiosity. I came out of it convinced of almost the opposite: that the Babylonian way of working showed me why the mathematics works, while the modern way mostly showed me that it works.

What the ancient solution taught me

The idea that changed my thinking was the missing sexagesimal point. At first, it looked like a defect: how can “1,15” mean 75, or 1¼, or anything in between? But presenting the ancient solution forced me to see it as a feature. By letting the long side of the triangle simply be “1”, the scribe was working with the shape of the triangle rather than its size, which is the idea of ratio and similarity, and the seed of trigonometry. The second lesson was the cut-and-paste square. I have written (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b² and d² − w² = (d + w)(d − w) for years, but only when I cut the square on 1;15 into four pieces and rearranged an L-shaped area into a rectangle of 2 × 0;30, did those formulas become things I could see and hold. Even dividing by multiplying with a reciprocal (igi 15 = 0;4) felt less like a trick and more like a sensible way to organize work with tables.

I also learned something about myself as a learner. Squaring 1;15 confused me at first, and I had to slow down and rebuild it, in the end, through the image of a clock: 1 hour 15 minutes, plus 15 minutes, plus 15 minutes, plus 3 minutes 45 seconds. That struggle was valuable. It reminded me how it feels when a familiar idea is written in an unfamiliar language, which is exactly how many of my future students may feel in a mathematics classroom.

What went well

The structure of our presentation (ancient solution, then modern, then a side-by-side comparison) let the class see that every modern step had an ancient partner. The highlight, for me, was the “Build your own triangle” activity: four groups took a reciprocal pair and became scribes themselves, producing (3, 4, 5), (5, 12, 13), (8, 15, 17) and (65, 72, 97), the last of which turns out to be row 5 of the actual tablet. Students were not just watching history; they were redoing it. Working as a team of three also meant each of us went deep into one part of the problem and then taught it to the others.

What needs to be improved

Our deck grew to nineteen slides for a twenty-minute slot, and some ideas (such as the extension on where row 11 came from) appeared twice. Next time I would cut ruthlessly and give more of the time to the class doing the mathematics: physically cutting a paper square rather than showing a diagram of one, and letting peers struggle with a step before we reveal the answer. I would also give more attention to the people behind the tablet (scribes, schools, and the purposes of record-keeping), and be more careful, as historians like Eleanor Robson urge, not to read our modern ideas, such as trigonometry, back into a culture that did not frame mathematics the way we do.

My takeaway

Ancient does not mean primitive. A formula is often a summary of a picture someone once drew, and when we teach only the summary, we take away the picture that makes it meaningful. As a future teacher, I want to start more often with the picture, the struggle and the story, and treat different ways of doing mathematics, whether historical, cultural or my students’ own, as different ways of seeing rather than as deficits. The question I will carry with me is simple: what are the “missing points” in my students’ thinking that are really strengths I have not yet learned to read?

 

1 comment:

  1. Bravo, Izhar! What a very thoughtful analysis of your experiences in doing this project and of what you take away for your own future teaching. Well done!!

    ReplyDelete

Numbers with Personality Reflection

In my school in Pakistan, numbers had no feelings. A number was something you added, carried, or wrote in the answer box. Alice Major’s essa...