When I went to school in Pakistan, the story of mathematics, when we heard any story at all, moved in a straight line: first Greece, then a long sleep called the Dark Ages, then Europe. In this chapter, Joseph draws that exact line as Figure 1.1 and calls it the “classical Eurocentric trajectory” (p. 4). Seeing the story from my own school years printed as an example of bias was my first shock. Three bigger surprises followed.
1. The oldest mathematics in the book comes from my own soil
In Joseph’s timeline (Figure 1.4), the history of Indian mathematics begins with the Harappan period: early mathematics evident in bricks, baths, and the planning of cities. Harappa and Mohenjo-daro are in Pakistan, in Punjab and Sindh. I grew up in the same country as these ancient cities, yet no math teacher ever told me that people there were measuring with care thousands of years before Euclid. A footnote also explains that the book’s “Arab” civilization includes non-Arab lands such as present-day Pakistan (p. 5). This surprised me because it shows that our problem was never a lack of history. We were taught to look for our history elsewhere. Joseph writes that people in power have always known that controlling the past helps them control the present (p. 1), and that former colonies can remain in “intellectual dependence” long after freedom (p. 2). Our textbooks in the 1990s were written by Pakistanis, but the map inside them was still drawn by someone else.
2. The “Dark Ages” were bright, just not in Europe
While Europe was “asleep,” the House of Wisdom in Baghdad brought together Indian, Greek, Babylonian and probably Chinese learning (pp. 10–11). Al-Khwarizmi’s book gave us the word algebra. The Arabic word jabr first meant setting a broken bone, and not long ago some barber shops in Spain still had signs offering “algebra and bloodletting” (p. 11). Algebra means putting broken parts back together, and that is also what this course is doing for my own story. But the chapter also showed me how easily credit gets lost. Al-Khwarizmi clearly said that the numerals came from India, yet Europe later called them “Arabic” numerals (p. 11). And Joseph notes that Arab scholars are often shown only as people who kept Greek books safe, not as people who created new mathematics (p. 8). That is the difference between a librarian and an author.
3. Great ideas were discovered many times, in many places
Place value was invented on its own four separate times: by the Babylonians, the Chinese, the Indians, and the Maya. Zero as a number was invented only twice, by the Maya and by the Indians (p. 22). The Maya measured the cycle of Venus as 584 days, missing by less than a tenth of a day, without glass, telescopes or clocks (p. 22). Around 1400, Madhava of Kerala found infinite series about 250 years before Newton and Leibniz (p. 20). This surprised me most because it changed my question. I used to ask, “Who was first?” Now I ask, “What does it mean that so many different people reached the same ideas?” To me, it means that the ability to create mathematics belongs to all human beings, not to one culture (p. 2).
What I will carry into my classroom
Joseph honestly admits that his book does not study the mathematics of Africans south of the Sahara or of the Indigenous peoples of North America in enough detail (p. 22). His honesty is a lesson too: every map leaves something out. In BC, I will teach on the lands of First Peoples, whose mathematics is also missing from most maps. My job is not to swap one center for another. My job is to draw the map with many arrows, the way Joseph does in Figure 1.4, and to ask my students: “Whose mathematics is missing here, and where do you see yourself on this map?”
Wow! Your writing about Joseph's book is every bit as interesting as the book itself. There is so much to think about here! I also feel the missing stories of the mathematics of the First Peoples of these lands, and of most of Africa (aside from the the well-known Ishango Bone, which is clearly not representative of all that has been worked on discovered throughout Africa. Similarly, the mathematics of Indigenous peoples of Australia, New Zealand and the South Pacific Islands are barely included in these historical narratives. There is much research and writing to do in these areas!
ReplyDelete