Before reading: what I thought math history was for
In my government school in Pakistan in the 1990s, mathematics arrived as a finished building, and no one told us who built it. We copied theorems, memorized textbook solutions, and repeated them in exams. We called the skill that earned marks 'ratta', learning by heart. Nobody asked where any of it came from. Before this reading, I already believed that history belongs in my math teaching, but for a narrow reason: justice. I wanted to tell students that the words algebra and algorithm come from al-Khwarizmi, a scholar in Baghdad. I wanted them to know that our textbooks jumped from the Greeks to Europe and left out hundreds of years of work written in Arabic and Persian. For me, history was a way to put the missing names back and restore some of the pride we had lost.
Three Places Where I Stopped
The Ice. The article quotes Freudenthal, who says that when mathematicians publish, they turn “hot invention into icy beauty” (p. 204). The exciting search is hidden, and only the clean final answer is shown. This was exactly my school experience: I only ever got the ice. The authors suggest that students should meet a new idea after they feel a need for it (p. 208). This helped me understand why formulas felt arbitrary to me. We were given answers to questions that no one let us ask. My good marks and grades hid the fact that I often did not know why a method existed and worked.
The Warning Against Chauvinism. One objection in the article says that history can make people too proud of their own culture and narrow in their view of others (p. 203). This made me uncomfortable, because part of my plan was to replace one proud story with another. The article offers a better idea. A school in Hong Kong showed students proofs of the Pythagorean theorem from China, Babylon, Greece and India side by side (p. 218). The goal was not to decide who came first, but to show that people in many places found the same truth in different ways. I also noticed, with a small smile, that this long article about many cultures mentions al-Khwarizmi only once. Even careful scholars repeat the silences I grew up with, so some of this work of remembering will be mine to do.
A really beautiful reflection on this reading and many experiences that connect with it. I especially appreciate your thoughts as a teacher!
ReplyDelete